Platos Republic - Philosopher Queens - 1629 Words

| FIRST PERM PAPER | TOPIC # 6 | | RONEN LEVSHTEIN | 206-325-492OCTOBER 6, 2010 | | Even though the definition â€Å"Philosopher Queens† itself is not mentioned in the text, Plato refers to them as ‘these’ women who are capable of performing the same tasks and follow the same obligations as men. The questions as to why he thinks this way lies in his understanding of human nature and his theory of virtue. For this argument Plato used Socrates view of women’s nature and place in the city to elaborate on his own views. It is important to say that Socrates was dragged to talk about this issue, as he himself thought he finished investigating the city. He also feared the subject as he himself did not know much about it. He feared†¦show more content†¦Hence, how is it possible for women to do the same tasks as men when they are so different and distinct in nature? After some thought he realized that they were concentrating on the contradiction of that was said, rather than dividing it into forms, and analyzing it case by case. He portrayed them as falling into a sea of argument, and they must do anything and everything to swim their way out or be rescued by some other hopeless means. The reason for the dilemma was that they were falling into a dispute among themselves, rather than having a conversation, whereas they examine all point and forms of view. When this was realized he then moved to discuss the subject by focusing on the difference of the natural forms they were trying to distinguish. He uses the example of Bald verses Long-Haired men for if their natures are different or similar. For if we do think they are different, we should agree that one of them cannot be a cobbler while the other is, and this is ridiculous. He furthers it by using another example, whereas he says that a woman doctor and a man doctor have the same nature, while a doctor and a carpenter have different one. He then concludes that if women are different from men with regards to a specific task, or way of life, it should be agreed that a specific and different task should be assignedShow MoreRelatedThe Big Three Ancient Greek Philosophers1107 Words   |  5 Pagesmonarchs and dictators of some of the greatest nations in the world such as Julius Caesar, Queen Elizabeth, and George Washington. Others may include war heroes such as Achilles, Alexander the Great, and George Armstrong Custer. Yet, some of the most influential people in history also represent some of the least known. A majority of these individuals are philosophers such as Plato and Aristotle. These two philosophers are regarded as two of what some call the Big Three of Philosophy. â€Å"Socrates, Plato,Read MorePolitical Theory Has Changed Over The History Of The World1608 Words   |  7 Pagesdiscipline. Two of the most influential and arguably most important theorists are the Greek philosopher Plato, and the Renaissanceâ €™s Niccolo Machiavelli. These two characters represent the beginning of idealistic political thought, and a more realist and contemporary way that politics are looked at even today. The ideals of these two will be discussed and dissected, to some extent to show how unobtainable Plato’s ideal is compared to Machiavelli’s realism that is seen in today’s political atmosphereRead MoreEssay about Platos De Feminization of The Republic1731 Words   |  7 PagesPlatos De Feminization of The Republic Platos suggestion that female guardians do everything male guardians do is a radical and revolutionary proposal in a time when women were viewed as property. However there are complexities and contradictions in the Platonic text on female equality. He makes obvious statements and allusions those women are more cowardly, less trustworthy, innately worse then men. In Book V, he emphasizes that women, as a class are equals to men in capacity, although onRead MoreComparing Aristotle s 8 1455 Words   |  6 Pagestopic in The Republic. In Plato s book the ones who have a passion for intellectual thought, which constitutes contemplative reasoning, science and mathematics. In every way they both Aristotle and Plato say think the same about how to exercise your virtue with higher thinking. However Plato made it clear that it was talking about philosophers. As he starts to reference the story about the man in the cave who has â€Å"seen the outside world†, which is supposed to be an allegory for philosophers and how theyRead MoreA Tale Of Alexander Romance And A True Story1783 Words   |  8 Pagesoccurs to magic which will form his character, through Nektanabos, his biological father. In this introduction, magic is used for deception. Nektanabos portrays himself as an Egyptian prophet, and â€Å"his calculations were of such accuracy that even the queen Olympias heard of him† With further use of enchantment and prophecy he gains access to Olympias and disguised as a god impregnates her with Alexander. These trickster elements first encountered through the magic of Nektanabos, later come into playRead MoreEssay on Socrates Is Not Guilty1909 Words   |  8 PagesIn the book, Plato Republic, Socrates had a discussion with Thrasymachus and Glaucon about justice and unjustice. In this essay, I shall argue that Plato’s solution of the temptation of the ring is successful in a few ways. I will describe Thrasymachus and Glaucon’s idea about justice, and how Socrates discuss with them in terms of the justice of the city, justice of individual soul, his theory of forms and the importance of the knowledge of the good, and the sun analogy and the allegory of the caveRead MoreAnimalistic Behavior In Platos Republic And The Aeneid1772 Words   |  8 Pagesanimal. Famous philosophers and poets toyed with the idea of what truly sets human behavior apart from animalistic behavior by presenting the idea that animalistic behavior is prominently propelled by appetites and desires. Th e ability to overcome these appetitive tendencies and to think with reason distinguishes human from animal. Once humans are able to balance the soul with reason, they can live virtuously. This ability to become a virtuous being is demonstrated throughout Plato’s Republic and Virgil’sRead MoreSuperheroes And Philosophy : Truth, Justice, And The Socratic Way1880 Words   |  8 Pagesand personal responsibility along with others. Tom Morris and Matt Morris edited the book, Superheroes and Philosophy: Truth, Justice, and the Socratic Way, which showed how superhero comics and movies are related to the writings of many great philosophers. Each chapter connects superheroes to certain philosophical issues. One chapter considers the superheroes’ motivation for their actions for helping others in need. Superheroes need to make sacrifices in order to help others. In addition, someRead MoreThe s Defence Of Injustice1733 Words   |  7 PagesIn this essay I will discuss Glaucon’s defence of injustice, which he presents to Socrates in book 11 of Plato’s The Republic. For the purposes of this paper, I will focus on the overriding theme in Glaucon’s argument; that we are only just for the sake of consequences and will conclude by agreeing with this notion. Glaucon, dissatisfied with previous appraisals of justice, seeks to challenge Socrates by strengthening Thrasymachus’ defence of injustice in book 1. ‘This is exactly what he gives usRead MorePlatos The Last Days of Socrates: Phaedo, Wisdom, and the Soul2420 Words   |  10 Pagesï » ¿Read the following in Platos The Last Days of Socrates: Phaedo Wisdom and the Soul Plato sees death as a good thing and the way we can understand this is by reference to the Platonic forms. The platonic forms are the essence of the abstract; they are the purity and the true Good that are clouded by materialism. For instance, we have beauty that is hidden in aesthetic objects (or in love); we have Justice, Truth, and many other Ideals. Access to these Ideals affords us true bliss and Knowledge